A pilgrimage to Orwell’s Barnhill 

A view of the Scottish island of Jura where George Orwell took up residence.
| Photo Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto

George Orwell
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement

On the island of Jura live more deer and sheep than people. Five miles of trudging beyond the main road will bring you to a croft now called Knockavill, or as George Orwell named it, Barnhill, where he set up a frugal farmhouse and wrote his classic 1984. This Hebridean island in Scotland has always been an abiding fascination for me, as I too, like Orwell, sought its isolation and peace, its beauty and remoteness, its ruggedness and wildlife, its solitude and its adventure.

Scotland holds a special enchantment for me, and I have found myself drawn back to its rolling hills, placid lochs, and peaceful streams time and again. My sense of a lonely man mourning the death of his wife, Eileen, and suffering from frequent bouts of tuberculosis in a homestead in austere surroundings of a faraway windswept island, piqued my curiosity, inspiring me to embark on a journey to this isolated island; its eerie stillness has always seized my imagination. Amid the cacophony of modern life, where every experience is recorded and shared, I too find solace in the simplicity and quiet of this unfettered place.

Orwell’s decision to settle here was initially driven by a whimsical claim to Scottish lineage, but his true intention was to seek refuge from the constant demands of the “tyranny of the telephone”. He was entranced by the bleak beauty and the loneliness of the Highlands, so vividly captured by Daniel Defoe. Orwell had envisioned a self-sufficient life, cultivating his own food and living off the land in this serene haven. The unforgiving environment proved a far cry from his pastoral vision but he derived a perverse pleasure and a comfort that became his objective correlative of the reeling consequences of carnage and debris of war-torn Europe. He had moved here in September 1945 considering the wet moorland as a location for reflection on the abysmal devastation that followed the war. Its very inaccessibility sharpened his appetite for an idyllic life.

Sheltered refuge

Even today, this enigmatic retreat remains a sheltered refuge, accessible only by boat, which can be anchored in the bay near the small settlement of Craighouse. With no bridge or direct link to the mainland, this out-of-the-way island is home to just 200 residents, a single renowned distillery producing exceptional single malts, a solitary shop, and a modest hotel. Yet, for the intrepid traveller willing to venture off the beaten path, this isolated sanctuary holds a special allure. It was here, in a remote farmhouse perched on the coast, that George Orwell found the seclusion to complete his masterpiece, 1984. The same farmhouse, set amidst the rolling hills and craggy shoreline that Orwell cultivated with devotion, still stands as a poignant reminder of the transformative power of isolation and dedication. This testament to the power of solitude and creativity was a little unsettling in the beginning, particularly the quietness juxtaposed with the intervening noise of war and death. Though unobtrusive and calm, I experienced the cold strong winds lashing the bleak and lonesome farmhouse Orwell once lived in. It still stands there, a harbinger of the world that Orwell so vividly created, foretelling the dark history that lay in wait for humanity. A perfect metaphor for today, 1984 holds an immense value and urgent warning for our times.

Orwell’s warnings about the abuse of power and the dangers of totalitarianism descended upon me like a dark, ominous cloud. As I pondered on his insights on power’s corrupting influence, the ominous spectres of “Big Brother” and the “thought police” loomed over me like a foreboding shadow, haunting not just classic dictatorships but also our contemporary post-truth reality. Beyond the bleak, post-war landscape of T.S. Eliot’s The Wasteland, I imagined the dystopian world of 1984, where the all-pervasive “Big Brother” suffocates individual freedom. And yet, in this desolate landscape, I saw Orwell standing resolute, his gaze fixed on the turbulent sea symbolising the unbreakable human spirit that refuses to yield to the tempests of oppression and inequality.

At the heart of humanism lies indeed a profound transformative power, which Orwell saw as capable of liberating even the most exploited among us from their oppressors. This inner strength, rooted in a deep spiritual faith, enables individuals, as Orwell wrote, to tap into their vital energy and break free from the shackles of exploitation, much “like a horse shaking off flies”.

This was a poignant lament, a desperate cry in the face of a dystopian reality where data become the dominant currency, stripping us of our autonomy. In this digital age of surveillance, our personal preferences, desires, and political leanings are no longer our own, but are instead commodified and manipulated. The relentless march of technological progress has left us desensitised, our sensitivity eroded by the constant barrage of threats to our privacy, individuality, and humanity.

shelleywalia@gmail.com